Hey, guys let me just say I'm new and love love makeup. I refuse to spend a ton of money on high end make up, for me it's drug store or bust. Now to the eyeliner lol. I have used the rimmel exaggerate eyeliner but I recently bought the scandal eyes eyeliner and so far it has been great. It stays where you want it and doesn't smudge. It last a long time. Easy to apply. I feel like it is going to be hard to sharpen though. I haven't really had any problems with yet. I couldn't find it to a review so here it is.